When she finds out that the victim's wallet was missing, Jody tells the Winchesters about the missing belt on the first victim. While she was planning to head to the morgue again, Sam informs her they just went and all the flesh was eaten off of the second victim too. When Sam & Dean show up the next morning, Jody is at first annoyed to see them as she told them she could handle it. While Donna suggests they hang out together, Jody decides to go to bed instead. Jody explains that she's grown frustrated with her inability to get through to Alex and Donna comforts her about it. Donna arrives and points out how Jody's life isn't perfect either and then gets annoyed as Jody was leaving without her until Jody explains there was another attack and she was going to go check the morgue until she realized it was probably closed. Afterwards, Jody calls Alex and is annoyed with her, especially when she hears firecrackers in the background. After Donna leaves, Jody confronts Len who admits that someone else turned up dead and he is trying to keep it quiet to not spoil everyone's good time. She finds the sheriff to try and gauge if he knows more about the attacks, Jody and Donna approach him, but he is unhelpful until his deputy pulls him away to tell him about another victim under the guise of telling him about a "raffle." Jody doesn't believe him about the raffle and is disgusted at Doug's actions, telling Donna that he seems like a "dick." Donna tells her she still cares and then heads off to get away from the disgusting display. After Donna tells her that she can't recognize the bite of what killed the man, Jody grows worried as she knows it must be a monster after all and not a wild animal. While Donna examines the body, Jody asks for the man's personal effects and is surprised to find that his pants have no belt. However, Donna arrives and convinces her to let them see the body. Wanting to check out the body, Jody goes to the morgue but the coroner, Shelly refuses to let her in. Despite this, they decide to come anyway. Jody tells Sam & Dean about the body, but refuses their help and says she'll call if she needs them. Jody is annoyed that Sam didn't tell her Dean was no longer missing.
The boys are researching the Mark of Cain to but have found nothing in the Men of Letters library or files. Recognizing that it might be a monster, Jody excuses herself and calls Sam & Dean. While seeing what activities there are to do at the retreat, Jody gets interested when another sheriff mentions that a body was found eaten nearly whole with no clues and the local police believing it to be an animal attack.
However, she is annoyed by Sheriff Doug Kontos' rudeness to Donna & Donna explains that Doug is her ex-husband.Īfter talking to Alex and trusting her not to throw a party while she's gone, Jody finds that she has to partner with Donna for the duration of the retreat. Inside, she meets Sheriff Donna Hanscum and is disconcerted by Donna's overly-friendly attitude.
On her way in, she encounters a young beggar, Starr, who she gives some money to get lunch. Jody is forced to go to a sheriff's retreat in Hibbing, Minnesota, by the mayor of Sioux Falls despite having Alex to look after and a lot of work to do.